SupremeCourt

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Madras High Court strikes down amendment to S.126 of Patents Act

Posted on 12:35 PM by Unknown
As discussed in our previous post, this post brings forth our analysis of some aspects of this important judgment.  The judgment was provided to us by Mr. S.P. Chockalingam, the petitioner in the case.  The judgment may be accessed directly here (Writ Petition 8472 of 2006).

The judgment declares the amendment introduced to Section 126 of the Patents Act, 1970, by Section 67 (a) of the Patents (Amendment) Act, 2005 as illegal, unconstitutional, ultra vires and void.  Basically it allows all advocates to practice before the patent office without giving the patent agent exam.  

The Madras High Court (MHC) held that "..[M]erely by prescribing qualification, as degree holder in science, engineering or technology and passing a Departmental Examination on Patents Act and drafting, the respondents cannot monopolise such category of persons and say that Advocates are not competent to be patent agents  and similarly the right that was available to advocates under Section 126 (1) (c) (i) of the Act, could not be taken away against the  Constitutional safeguards, by way of the impugned amendment."
It is important to note that the MHC treats the patent agent examination as a departmental examination, and treats the same as a gimmick.

In my view the judgment actually goes too far in providing the benefit (of appearing before the patent office) to lawyers without a science background.  The logic is somewhat circular - law is (social) science (paragraph 23) - and that the patent office cannot take the view contrary to that of eminent jurists that a lawyer is (social) engineer!!    

Our readers would be aware of the decision of the Delhi High Court (DHC) in the case of Anvita Singh - upholding the patent agent examination and reducing the weightage for viva as discussed here.  The MHC judgment is penned by a single judge whereas the DHC decision is by a division bench - For this reason the MHC judgment contradicts part of the DHC decision.

Some comments to the previous post argued that if someone could argue a patent case, then it was good reason for them to be able to practice before the patent office.  These comments seem ignorant of the fact that the primary role in writing a patent application and arguing a patent case are poles apart.  An analogy is appropriate here: Consider the task of demolition of a building - there are many ways to break it down - and among them could be use hammers, dynamite etc., or a civil engineer might opine to break down selected beams, pillars so that the entire building comes down under its own weight.  Now consider the task of building a structure or a house - it has to be precise and ordered.  
When applying to patent law, when arguing for or against a patent - the skill that is being used is not the same skill to write the patent application.  The same argument can be made about judgement skills that go for adjudicating a patent case. 
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in 126, Patent, patent agent exam qualifications, Rajiv, writ | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Guest Post: Intermediary liability in defamation cases - Parle, Mouthshut & Visakha cases to clarify the law
    Chaitanya Ramachandran, who has blogged for us previously over here and here , has sent us this excellent guest post analyzing the extent of...
  • IP Research Assistant position at IIT, Madras
    Feroz Ali Khader, MHRD IP Chair at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras, is looking for research assistants to work on various is...
  • Guest Post: A Step Forward and a Step Back for the Print Disabled
    We are happy to bring our readers our first guest post entry from our SpicyIP Fellowship applicants. Snigdha Roy, a 3rd year student from G...
  • Open Access: What is it about?
    Aaron Swartz' s recent suicide has sparked discussion all over the internet, with much of it to do with his  strong belief in the moral ...
  • Delhi University Restrained for Alleged Admission of Infringement: True Lies?
    This afternoon, in response to my post announcing a petition relating to the OUP-Delhi University copyright dispute, we were informed that...
  • SPICY IP TIDBIT: IPAB reverts “DARJEELING LOUNGE” matter to Registrar
    Background ITC Limited, the appellant, applied for the mark “DARJEELING LOUNGE” which was advertised on 07.02.2005.  Notice of opposition ...
  • Del HC hits a sixer: The Boundaries of Copyright and Cricket
    Our friends at Medianama have pointed us in the direction of one of the most superbly analysed IP judgments that I have read in a long time...
  • SpicyIP Tidbit: An IP Thriller from an IP lawyer
    In an exciting first for the community of intellectual property lawyers in India, Dr. Kalyan Kankanala has penned a thriller novel based, w...
  • Royal Orchid Hotels scores a crucial trademark victory in its long running battle with the Kamat Group
    In a decision dated 18th June, 2013 a bench of the Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB), has allowed the appeals filed by Royal Orch...
  • Guest Post: The New India Guidelines on Similar Biologics
    The Government of India has recently announced certain guidelines regulating the approval of 'similar biologics' also known as bio-s...

Categories

  • 126 (1)
  • 3(d) (4)
  • 3(f) (1)
  • 3(i) (1)
  • 3(k) (2)
  • Academic Writing (1)
  • access (10)
  • access to food (1)
  • access to health (3)
  • AIA (1)
  • AIDS/HIV (3)
  • Antitrust (2)
  • Bajaj v LML (1)
  • Basmati Row (2)
  • Biological Diversity (5)
  • Biologics (2)
  • biopiracy (4)
  • biotech (7)
  • Bollywood (25)
  • Broadcasters Rights (5)
  • Budget (1)
  • business method patent (2)
  • Call for papers (2)
  • Cipla (2)
  • Comparative Advertising (4)
  • Competition law (8)
  • Compulsory Licensing (27)
  • condonation of delay (1)
  • Conference (4)
  • Constitution (12)
  • Contracts (1)
  • Controller's decisions (8)
  • Copyright (112)
  • Copyright Amendment Bill 2010 (23)
  • copyright board (4)
  • Copyright Exceptions (6)
  • copyright office (1)
  • Copyright Rules (2013) (5)
  • Copyright Societies (9)
  • Counterfeiting (1)
  • creativity (1)
  • Cross Retaliation (1)
  • csir (4)
  • d (1)
  • D.U. Photocopy Case (16)
  • Darjeeling Tea (3)
  • Data Exclusivity (2)
  • Database (1)
  • DCGI (2)
  • decompilation (2)
  • defamation (9)
  • Designs (3)
  • Designs Act (3)
  • Differential Pricing (2)
  • Dilution (1)
  • Disabilities (3)
  • Disability (2)
  • DMCA (2)
  • Doha Declaration (1)
  • Domain Names (2)
  • Draft Policy of the Indian Government (2)
  • DRM (1)
  • Drug Regulation (7)
  • education (12)
  • Enercon (1)
  • Enforcement (1)
  • EU (2)
  • ex parte (2)
  • exhaustion (3)
  • Exhaustion of Rights (2)
  • Fair Dealing (8)
  • Fair Use (11)
  • Federal Circuit (1)
  • Fees (3)
  • FICCI (7)
  • FRAND (2)
  • free trade agreement (3)
  • FTA (3)
  • G.I. Registry (4)
  • gene sequences (3)
  • Generic medicine (4)
  • Geographical Indication (14)
  • Gilead (1)
  • Glenmark (5)
  • Gopika (34)
  • Guest post (11)
  • guidelines (1)
  • GWU-CII (1)
  • Herceptin (1)
  • hot news (3)
  • ICANN (1)
  • incremental innovation (1)
  • independence (1)
  • india (5)
  • Indian Government (1)
  • Indian patent litigation (27)
  • Indian Pharma (35)
  • Injunction (10)
  • Innovation (7)
  • INTA (1)
  • Intermediaries (10)
  • internet (11)
  • Internet Access Providers (IAPs) (5)
  • Internet Censorship (7)
  • IP scholarship (3)
  • IP aware (4)
  • IP Course (3)
  • IP Education (1)
  • IP Policy (11)
  • IP update (4)
  • ip writing competition (1)
  • IPAB (34)
  • ipchair (1)
  • IPO (1)
  • IPRS (5)
  • IT Act (1)
  • Journal (2)
  • judicial independence (3)
  • Jurisdiction (1)
  • Kruttika (4)
  • Legal Education (3)
  • Legal Research Tools (1)
  • Legal Scholarship (2)
  • library (2)
  • Licensing (7)
  • Madhulika (20)
  • mathematical methods (1)
  • Media law (3)
  • medical method (1)
  • Merck (4)
  • mhrd ip chair (1)
  • Microsoft (3)
  • Middle Path (1)
  • Moral Rights (2)
  • Movies (18)
  • musical work (2)
  • nanotechnology (1)
  • Natco (3)
  • natco defamation suit (5)
  • natco vs bayer (4)
  • need for transparency (1)
  • Novartis (8)
  • Novartis patent case in India (11)
  • NPEs (2)
  • nujs (1)
  • NUJS Conference (2)
  • Obituary (1)
  • obviousness (7)
  • Off-Topic (2)
  • online course (4)
  • Open Access (6)
  • Open Source (2)
  • Opposition (3)
  • Parallel Imports (4)
  • Parliament (1)
  • passing off (5)
  • Patent (52)
  • Patent act (10)
  • patent agent (5)
  • patent agent exam (9)
  • patent agent exam qualifications (3)
  • patent infringement (5)
  • Patent Licensing (2)
  • Patent litigation (2)
  • Patent Office (19)
  • patent pool (3)
  • Patent Prosecution (7)
  • Patent rules (2)
  • Patent Strategies (8)
  • Patents (9)
  • pegasus (1)
  • Personality Rights (1)
  • Pfizer (1)
  • Pharma (18)
  • Piracy (5)
  • plagiarism (3)
  • Plant Variety Protection (2)
  • post grant (1)
  • Prashant (2)
  • Preventive Detention (1)
  • Price Control (6)
  • prior publication (1)
  • Privacy (3)
  • Prizes (1)
  • public health (3)
  • Public Interest (4)
  • Publicity Rights (4)
  • Publishing (3)
  • radio (2)
  • Rajiv (18)
  • Rectification Petition (2)
  • Rejection (1)
  • research (3)
  • reverse engineering (2)
  • revocation (4)
  • rip (1)
  • Roche (2)
  • Roche vs Cipla (1)
  • Royalty (2)
  • RTI (2)
  • Scholarship (4)
  • section 16 (1)
  • Section 3(d) (7)
  • section 8 (6)
  • shamnad (11)
  • Shan Kohli (4)
  • Shouvik Kumar Guha (30)
  • Smartphones/Tablets (2)
  • Social Innovation (1)
  • Software (10)
  • software enforcement (3)
  • software patent (3)
  • Special 301 Report (1)
  • Spicy Tidbits (6)
  • spicyip (1)
  • SpicyIP Accolades (1)
  • SpicyIP Announcements (9)
  • SpicyIP Case (1)
  • SpicyIP Cases (3)
  • spicyip commiseration (1)
  • SpicyIP Events (11)
  • SpicyIP Fellowship (5)
  • SpicyIP Guest Series (22)
  • SpicyIP Interview (2)
  • SpicyIP Jobs (4)
  • SpicyIP Jobs/General (2)
  • SpicyIP Review (1)
  • SpicyIP Tidbits (11)
  • SpicyIP Weekly Review (27)
  • Statutory Licensing (1)
  • STI Policy 2013 (4)
  • Sugen (3)
  • Supreme Court of India (5)
  • Swaraj (19)
  • Tarnishment (1)
  • Technology (6)
  • Technology Transfer (5)
  • TKDL (5)
  • TPP (1)
  • trade (4)
  • Trade Secret Protection (1)
  • Trademark (59)
  • Trademark dilution (1)
  • Trademark Registry (9)
  • Traditional Knowledge (7)
  • Transparency (5)
  • treaty (1)
  • trial (1)
  • tribunals (2)
  • TRIPS (11)
  • UK (3)
  • unfair competition (5)
  • UNFCCC (1)
  • Universities Research and Innovation Bill (2)
  • US (1)
  • US Patent Reform (1)
  • US Supreme Court (3)
  • viva (3)
  • WIPO (5)
  • Working a Patent (2)
  • Workshop (4)
  • writ (1)
  • WTO (1)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (364)
    • ►  September (13)
    • ►  August (41)
    • ►  July (36)
    • ►  June (36)
    • ►  May (32)
    • ▼  April (51)
      • Spicy IP Weekly Review: 4th Week of April, 2013
      • Guest Post: A look at the new notice and takedown ...
      • The patent litigation bug bites Indian pharma comp...
      • DU Copyright Controversy continues: Media joins th...
      • SPICY IP TIDBIT: IPAB reverts “DARJEELING LOUNGE” ...
      • SpicyIP Tidbit: SC stays release of Zanjeer 2.0
      • Hindu-Microsoft spar over AICTE story
      • The Kit Kat Trademark Dispute
      • Oops! IPO did it again: IPAB pulls up patent offic...
      • Guest Post: T-Series’ Constitutional Challenge to ...
      • SpicyIP Tidbit: Controller General restores name o...
      • SpicyIP Tidbit: Update on the Indo-EU FTA negotiat...
      • UK Supreme Court relieves internet users of the th...
      • Guest Post: Are Genes Eligible for Patents in the ...
      • Academics "Speak" Out in Coursepack Copyright Case
      • SPICY IP TIDBIT: Tea Board refused interim injunct...
      • Scoping the constitutional challenges against the ...
      • Guest Post: US Supreme Court hears oral arguments ...
      • IPAB complains, yet again, about lack of resources...
      • Publishers Support Fair Use. Really?
      • The Competition Commission tightens the 'noose' ar...
      • Does the Madras High Court judgment on S. 126 allo...
      • Call for Papers: NLSIU announces Consilience 2013 ...
      • 'Hamara Bajaj'- infringement of trademark of Bajaj...
      • Nautanki Saala: interim relief rejected by the Bom...
      • Delhi High Court scheduled to hear 3 petitions cha...
      • Victory has a thousand fathers – CPI(M) stakes cla...
      • Delhi HC on trademark protection for domain name
      • Madras High Court strikes down amendment to S.126 ...
      • Zanjeer Battle Continues: Scriptwriters Javed Akht...
      • CPI(M): Government negotiating adverse FTA terms
      • India Joins the International Trademark System
      • Thalappakatti biryani trademark row
      • SpicyIP Weekly Review (April- Week 1)
      • FICCI announces online certificate course on IPR a...
      • Investors protest Rise in Royalty Rates paid by As...
      • The salt form jinx:Delhi HC denies interim relief ...
      • Court Stays the Screeening of Ketan Mehta's Film
      • Deconstructing the judgment of the Supreme Court i...
      • Ramesh Sippy faces setback: Bombay High Court allo...
      • Bombay High Court paves the way for the release of...
      • Bombay HC rules on Zanjeer Controversy
      • FICCI announces online certificate course on intel...
      • SpicyIP Weekly Review(March- Week 5)
      • Spicy IP tidbit:Merck files patent infringement su...
      • Patent war intensifies: Glenmark launches generic ...
      • Clarification: Trademark Infringement Suit against...
      • EU gaining a double benefit: Free Trade and GI pro...
      • Supreme Court rejects bid by Novartis to patent Gl...
      • Increased copyright prices of vintage Bollywood so...
      • Officer's Choice v. Original Choice: IPAB allows C...
    • ►  March (66)
    • ►  February (40)
    • ►  January (49)
  • ►  2012 (131)
    • ►  December (29)
    • ►  November (42)
    • ►  October (50)
    • ►  September (10)
Powered by Blogger.