SupremeCourt

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, May 5, 2013

SpicyIP Weekly Review (May 2013, Week 1)

Posted on 11:01 AM by Unknown

SpicyIP is delighted to announce a new section on 'Social Innovations' focusing on innovations which are 'development oriented or specifically directed at social causes'. Swaraj brought our attention to world's first Braille smartphone developed by an Indian company, Kriyate Design Solutions. The phone enables visually impaired to send and receive text message, tactile maps, scan and convert external text to braille and even represent our surroundings in braille! The project is a brainchild of Sumit Dagar, a graduate from National Institute of Design.

Constitutionality challenge to Bollywood amendments

In this week's featured post, Prashant briefly takes us through the arguments raised by film producers led by Bharat Anand and JMV Movies Pvt. Ltd. against Sections 17, 18, 19 and 33 of the Copyright Act which were amended last year. This is part of our continuous coverage on three writ petitions filed before the Delhi High Court challenging the constitutionality of various provisions of the latest amendments.

(a) Second Proviso to Section 17: The petitioners alleged that the effect of insertion of second proviso to Section 17 excludes producers from claiming first ownership over the work. The petitioners argue that the provision unfairly discriminates producers wherein status quo is maintained for other copyright owners.

(b) Provisos to Sections 18 & 19: The petition alleged that the provisions which allow lyricists and composers to claim equal share of royalties earned by producers in relation to exploitation of their works is unreasonable and discriminatory to other classes of authors.

(c) Section 33: The film producers argue that the proviso of Section 33(1) violates Article 19(1)(c) which safeguards right to join (and right not to joint) an association. The provision mandatory requires the licensing of underlying works incorporated in cinematographic works to be administered through a copyright society.

For more on the strength of the arguments raised by film producers, Prashant's post is a must read.

Image from here
US Special 301 Report: India in the 'Priority Watch List' yet again

The US's Special 301 Report continues to place India in their 'Priority Watch List' and expectedly, the Supreme Court's decision on Section 3(d) and IPAB's decision on granting of India's first compulsory license were the prime targets. Maybe an ill informed opinion or a case of blatant misrepresentation, the report viewed the SC decision as a ban on incremental innovation in pharmaceutical industry. Furthermore, the report finds fault with the IPAB's ruling on 'local working requirement' necessitating inventors to manufacture in India, raising concerns over the spillovers to other sectors such as green technology and information and communication technology.

Swaraj in this post rightly questioned the legitimacy of the Special 301 report which of late echoes the opinions of corporate America without any deference to public health concerns in the developing world.

Justice Sridevan updates Madras High Court on IPAB's functioning 

Prashant reported the Central Government's continuing apathy towards DIPP as the IPAB chief Justice Prabha Sridevan submitted her second status report on the tribunal's functioning before the Madras High Court in the on-going challenge to tribunal's constitutionality. The first report was submitted 18 months ago (report available here). The latest report addresses two main issues concerning the Board; office space and financial requirements. The good news is that the space crunch seems to be resolved as extra space has opened up within the existing premises. Therefore, there no need for the Board to relocate itself to a new building sanctioned by DIPP which is currently under construction and three times more expensive than occupying the extra space. And for the bad news, the Board had to cancel few circuit hearings due to paucity of funds. The Board was granted Rs. 31.8 lakhs towards 'Office Expenses' as opposed to their proposal of Rs. 1.2 crores.

Justice Sridevan also noted a letter from Ministry of Law and Justice informing their efforts to streamline all tribunals, particularly to ensure uniformity in appointment and service conditions. Unfortunately, however, the DIPP continues to exert control over appointment of Board members.

IPAB allows opposition against registration of Jaguar

Image from here
Image from here
The IPAB on April 30, 2013, allowed an opposition filed by UK based car major, Jaguar Cars Limited in relation to registration of 'JAGUAR' sought by Swiss company, Manufacture Des Montres Jaguar, in relation to 'watches and parts thereof excluding clocks'. The Deputy Registrar of Trademarks, Kolkata dismissed the opposition on the grounds that the Swiss company was a prior applicant with respect to watches and that the opponent's registration does not extend to watches. The IPAB dismissing the order stated that Jaguar Cars Ltd. acquired wide reputation and brand value in India since its registration in 1945. Notwithstanding applicant's prior use of the mark in relation to watches, IPAB opined that the grant of registration is likely to cause confusion among consumers.

IP Courses 

The Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) has opened registration for an 'Online Certificate Course on Competition Law & Intellectual Property Rights' (IPComp). The course is open to law students, lawyers, industry professionals and students pursing company secretary courses. Last date for registration is May 25, 2013. For more details please visit www.ficciipcourse.in or email at ipcourse@ficci.com.

Off-topic

Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy (VCLP) [formerly Pre-Legislative Briefing Service (PBLS)], an independent think tank co-founded by Prashant Reddy and Arghya Sengupta is on a look out for research fellows and interns. In a very short span, VCLP has produced some cutting-edge research and policy work related to pending bill before the Parliament and has received much appreciation from Parliamentary Standing Committees examining these bills. The think think is currently headed by Arghya Sengupa, a Rhodes scholar at Oxford, and the last date for sending your applications is May 30, 2013.

International Developments

International status for GIs

The WIPO Working Group on the Development of the Lisbon System of Appellations of Origin met last week to discuss inclusion of geographical indications to the Lisbon Agreement for the Protection of Appellation of Origin and their International Registration. The latest move is an attempt to expand the membership to the treaty, as reported by Intellectual Property Watch. This round of discussions has brought more clarity in dealing with conflicts between earlier trademarks and registration of Appellation of Origin (AO) and GIs. The working group will reconvene in December 2013 to discuss further.

UKIPO proposes reforms to UK Design Rights

After an elaborate consultation process, the UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO) released a white paper suggesting amendments to its design laws and procedures. It recommended to amend the UK design protection to align with EU laws and has attempted to 'modernise and improve the design framework so that it is less complex to use'.Some of the key proposals include provision of criminal sanctions against copying of registered designs, retain and extend Unregistered UK Design Rights to businesses conducting operations in EU and permit a 30-month delay in publishing design application.

Image from here.
UK abandons plain packing laws for tobacco products (The Sun, Financial Times)

The British government has decided not to introduce plain packaging law for sale of tobacco products. An Australian style plain packaging law was doing rounds for more than a year in an attempt to de-glamorize  smoking among the youth. The UK tobacco lobby comprising two of the world's biggest tobacco companies, British American Tobacco and Imperial Tobacco, have continuously challenged the claim that plain packs dissuade tobacco consumption. In fact there is no credible evidence in Australia to indicate that  plain packs affect smoking, according various news reports.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in SpicyIP Weekly Review | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • IPAB on Payyannur Ring
    [*S lightly long post] Background: The Intellectual Property Appellate Board (“ IPAB ”), in its recent order in SubhashJewellery v. Payyan...
  • Guest Post: Intermediary liability in defamation cases - Parle, Mouthshut & Visakha cases to clarify the law
    Chaitanya Ramachandran, who has blogged for us previously over here and here , has sent us this excellent guest post analyzing the extent of...
  • Delhi HC rejects the "Hot News" Doctrine: A Summary
    The applicability of the Hot News doctrine was rejected recently in a landmark ruling delivered by Justice Bhat of the Delhi HC. This post i...
  • IP Research Assistant position at IIT, Madras
    Feroz Ali Khader, MHRD IP Chair at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras, is looking for research assistants to work on various is...
  • Satyajit Ray's sketches and copyright controversies
    A copyright row appears to have started between the Satyajit Ray Society and the Delhi Art Gallery, that is organising a countrywide exhibit...
  • Dorling Kindersley v. Sanguine Technical Publishers
    A recent Delhi High Court order passed on 21 January, 2013  with respect to copyright licensing has come to our notice. An analysis of the j...
  • Call for Papers: IIT Bombay and MHRD jointly announce the 2nd International Conference on Management of Intellectual Property and Strategy
    The readers may be interested to know that the Shailesh J. Mehta School of Management of IIT Bombay is geared up to host, in collaboration w...
  • SpicyIP Tidbit: ALCS August Distribution
    In the UK, the Authors' Licensing and Collecting Society is an organization run and owned by writers that collects money due to its mem...
  • Aaron Swartz, RIP
    See Cory Doctorow's eulogy here Some of us in India may not have heard of Aaron Swartz, a 26 year old activist who was heavily involved ...
  • Thalappakatti biryani trademark row
    The southern district of Dindigal in Tamil Nadu occupies a special place in the hearts of biryani lovers. In the late 1950s, one Nagasamy N...

Categories

  • 126 (1)
  • 3(d) (4)
  • 3(f) (1)
  • 3(i) (1)
  • 3(k) (2)
  • Academic Writing (1)
  • access (10)
  • access to food (1)
  • access to health (3)
  • AIA (1)
  • AIDS/HIV (3)
  • Antitrust (2)
  • Bajaj v LML (1)
  • Basmati Row (2)
  • Biological Diversity (5)
  • Biologics (2)
  • biopiracy (4)
  • biotech (7)
  • Bollywood (25)
  • Broadcasters Rights (5)
  • Budget (1)
  • business method patent (2)
  • Call for papers (2)
  • Cipla (2)
  • Comparative Advertising (4)
  • Competition law (8)
  • Compulsory Licensing (27)
  • condonation of delay (1)
  • Conference (4)
  • Constitution (12)
  • Contracts (1)
  • Controller's decisions (8)
  • Copyright (112)
  • Copyright Amendment Bill 2010 (23)
  • copyright board (4)
  • Copyright Exceptions (6)
  • copyright office (1)
  • Copyright Rules (2013) (5)
  • Copyright Societies (9)
  • Counterfeiting (1)
  • creativity (1)
  • Cross Retaliation (1)
  • csir (4)
  • d (1)
  • D.U. Photocopy Case (16)
  • Darjeeling Tea (3)
  • Data Exclusivity (2)
  • Database (1)
  • DCGI (2)
  • decompilation (2)
  • defamation (9)
  • Designs (3)
  • Designs Act (3)
  • Differential Pricing (2)
  • Dilution (1)
  • Disabilities (3)
  • Disability (2)
  • DMCA (2)
  • Doha Declaration (1)
  • Domain Names (2)
  • Draft Policy of the Indian Government (2)
  • DRM (1)
  • Drug Regulation (7)
  • education (12)
  • Enercon (1)
  • Enforcement (1)
  • EU (2)
  • ex parte (2)
  • exhaustion (3)
  • Exhaustion of Rights (2)
  • Fair Dealing (8)
  • Fair Use (11)
  • Federal Circuit (1)
  • Fees (3)
  • FICCI (7)
  • FRAND (2)
  • free trade agreement (3)
  • FTA (3)
  • G.I. Registry (4)
  • gene sequences (3)
  • Generic medicine (4)
  • Geographical Indication (14)
  • Gilead (1)
  • Glenmark (5)
  • Gopika (34)
  • Guest post (11)
  • guidelines (1)
  • GWU-CII (1)
  • Herceptin (1)
  • hot news (3)
  • ICANN (1)
  • incremental innovation (1)
  • independence (1)
  • india (5)
  • Indian Government (1)
  • Indian patent litigation (27)
  • Indian Pharma (35)
  • Injunction (10)
  • Innovation (7)
  • INTA (1)
  • Intermediaries (10)
  • internet (11)
  • Internet Access Providers (IAPs) (5)
  • Internet Censorship (7)
  • IP scholarship (3)
  • IP aware (4)
  • IP Course (3)
  • IP Education (1)
  • IP Policy (11)
  • IP update (4)
  • ip writing competition (1)
  • IPAB (34)
  • ipchair (1)
  • IPO (1)
  • IPRS (5)
  • IT Act (1)
  • Journal (2)
  • judicial independence (3)
  • Jurisdiction (1)
  • Kruttika (4)
  • Legal Education (3)
  • Legal Research Tools (1)
  • Legal Scholarship (2)
  • library (2)
  • Licensing (7)
  • Madhulika (20)
  • mathematical methods (1)
  • Media law (3)
  • medical method (1)
  • Merck (4)
  • mhrd ip chair (1)
  • Microsoft (3)
  • Middle Path (1)
  • Moral Rights (2)
  • Movies (18)
  • musical work (2)
  • nanotechnology (1)
  • Natco (3)
  • natco defamation suit (5)
  • natco vs bayer (4)
  • need for transparency (1)
  • Novartis (8)
  • Novartis patent case in India (11)
  • NPEs (2)
  • nujs (1)
  • NUJS Conference (2)
  • Obituary (1)
  • obviousness (7)
  • Off-Topic (2)
  • online course (4)
  • Open Access (6)
  • Open Source (2)
  • Opposition (3)
  • Parallel Imports (4)
  • Parliament (1)
  • passing off (5)
  • Patent (52)
  • Patent act (10)
  • patent agent (5)
  • patent agent exam (9)
  • patent agent exam qualifications (3)
  • patent infringement (5)
  • Patent Licensing (2)
  • Patent litigation (2)
  • Patent Office (19)
  • patent pool (3)
  • Patent Prosecution (7)
  • Patent rules (2)
  • Patent Strategies (8)
  • Patents (9)
  • pegasus (1)
  • Personality Rights (1)
  • Pfizer (1)
  • Pharma (18)
  • Piracy (5)
  • plagiarism (3)
  • Plant Variety Protection (2)
  • post grant (1)
  • Prashant (2)
  • Preventive Detention (1)
  • Price Control (6)
  • prior publication (1)
  • Privacy (3)
  • Prizes (1)
  • public health (3)
  • Public Interest (4)
  • Publicity Rights (4)
  • Publishing (3)
  • radio (2)
  • Rajiv (18)
  • Rectification Petition (2)
  • Rejection (1)
  • research (3)
  • reverse engineering (2)
  • revocation (4)
  • rip (1)
  • Roche (2)
  • Roche vs Cipla (1)
  • Royalty (2)
  • RTI (2)
  • Scholarship (4)
  • section 16 (1)
  • Section 3(d) (7)
  • section 8 (6)
  • shamnad (11)
  • Shan Kohli (4)
  • Shouvik Kumar Guha (30)
  • Smartphones/Tablets (2)
  • Social Innovation (1)
  • Software (10)
  • software enforcement (3)
  • software patent (3)
  • Special 301 Report (1)
  • Spicy Tidbits (6)
  • spicyip (1)
  • SpicyIP Accolades (1)
  • SpicyIP Announcements (9)
  • SpicyIP Case (1)
  • SpicyIP Cases (3)
  • spicyip commiseration (1)
  • SpicyIP Events (11)
  • SpicyIP Fellowship (5)
  • SpicyIP Guest Series (22)
  • SpicyIP Interview (2)
  • SpicyIP Jobs (4)
  • SpicyIP Jobs/General (2)
  • SpicyIP Review (1)
  • SpicyIP Tidbits (11)
  • SpicyIP Weekly Review (27)
  • Statutory Licensing (1)
  • STI Policy 2013 (4)
  • Sugen (3)
  • Supreme Court of India (5)
  • Swaraj (19)
  • Tarnishment (1)
  • Technology (6)
  • Technology Transfer (5)
  • TKDL (5)
  • TPP (1)
  • trade (4)
  • Trade Secret Protection (1)
  • Trademark (59)
  • Trademark dilution (1)
  • Trademark Registry (9)
  • Traditional Knowledge (7)
  • Transparency (5)
  • treaty (1)
  • trial (1)
  • tribunals (2)
  • TRIPS (11)
  • UK (3)
  • unfair competition (5)
  • UNFCCC (1)
  • Universities Research and Innovation Bill (2)
  • US (1)
  • US Patent Reform (1)
  • US Supreme Court (3)
  • viva (3)
  • WIPO (5)
  • Working a Patent (2)
  • Workshop (4)
  • writ (1)
  • WTO (1)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (364)
    • ►  September (13)
    • ►  August (41)
    • ►  July (36)
    • ►  June (36)
    • ▼  May (32)
      • Haldiram Bhujiawala: IPAB Order
      • Guest Post: Impugning novelty the Novartis way
      • Comparative Advertising: Reckitt Benckiser trumps ...
      • The (Great) Gatsby Files: IPAB decides in favour o...
      • SpicyIP Weekly Review (May 4th Week)
      • Comparative Advertising: Delhi HC (Reckitt Benckis...
      • Drug price control order (DPCO) 2013 : What's in s...
      • Micolube: Dual Protection and the Doctrine of Elec...
      • SpicyIP Tidbit: IPXI releases latest edition of i...
      • The Times Publishing House threatens to sue our bl...
      • Microsoft v. Motorola: A FRAND-ly formula for fixi...
      • Guest Post: A rejoinder from the IPKat
      • WIPS (Worldwide Intellectual Property Service) – I...
      • The curious case of medical method patent: Can doc...
      • Guest Post: A response to the IPKat's "despair" by...
      • Javed Akhtar nominated for CISAC Vice-Presidency
      • Guest Post: A quick update on Viacom v. YouTube
      • Guest post: Avoiding Open Source Surprises When Bu...
      • Guest Post: The IPKat's "despair" with the Supreme...
      • Comparative Advertising: Delhi HC (SAFFOLA v. FORT...
      • SpicyIP Events: Registrations for Consilience 2013...
      • IPAB upholds validity of Bajaj Auto's patent in re...
      • SpicyIP Tidbit: Update on Zanjeer and Bombay Talkies
      • The Ericsson-Micromax patent litigation: Where is ...
      • SpicyIP Weekly Review (May 2013, Week 1)
      • The Jaguar Trademark Conundrum
      • Social Innovations: A Braille Smartphone
      • USTR's Special 301 Process 2013 - India on Priorit...
      • The constitutional challenge by film producers to ...
      • FICCI announces online certificate course on compe...
      • Justice Sridevan’s status report to the Madras Hig...
      • Job openings at the Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy
    • ►  April (51)
    • ►  March (66)
    • ►  February (40)
    • ►  January (49)
  • ►  2012 (131)
    • ►  December (29)
    • ►  November (42)
    • ►  October (50)
    • ►  September (10)
Powered by Blogger.